Isaiah Mustafa - Actor Profile

Isaiah Mustafa

Acting
Updated: Apr 11, 2026
20Total Films
10.0 Highest Rated
Born: Feb 11, 1974
Birth Place: Portland, Oregon, USA

About Isaiah Mustafa

Isaiah Mustafa (born February 11, 1974 height 6' 3½" (1,92 m)) is an American actor and former NFLpractice squadwide receiver. Mustafa is widely known as the main character for a series of Old Spice TV commercials, The Man Your Man Could Smell Like, for portraying Luke Garroway on Freeform's fantasy series Shadowhunters, and as adult Mike Hanlon in It Chapter Two (2019). Mustafa was born in Portland, Oregon, the youngest of seven children of Shahidah Mustafa-Davis and John Wali Mustafa, who owned and ran a limousine service in Laguna Hills, California in the early 1980s. Mustafa studied history at Arizona State and he played during the 1997 Rose Bowl between the then-undefeated Sun Devils and the Ohio State Buckeyes. Although Mustafa expected to become a high school teacher after graduation, a sports agent suggested that he try out for NFL teams. The Tennessee Oilers signed him to the practice squad, then sent him to NFL Europe's Barcelona Dragons in 1998. After a season on the Oakland Raiders and Cleveland Browns' practice squads in 1999, Mustafa attended the Seattle Seahawks' training camp in 2000. Next he owned a restaurant called Jo Jo's Barbecue on Melrose Avenue in Los Angeles that has since closed. Mustafa is a comic book fan; his knowledge of Doctor Doom's first name helped him win $47,000 on The Weakest Link, for a question on the first name of Doctor Frankenstein. The money helped him pursue his post-restaurateur goal of becoming an actor.

Isaiah Mustafa Movies & Career Overview

The filmography of Isaiah Mustafa reflects a career marked by diverse experimentation. Across 20 major appearances, the actor has built a reputation through performances in multiple genres and storytelling styles.

Dominant Genre

A large portion of Isaiah Mustafa's work falls within the Comedy genre, where audiences tend to respond most strongly to their on-screen presence.

Success Ratio

Approximately 40% of Isaiah Mustafa's films maintain ratings above 6.5, indicating a consistent level of audience approval.

One of the most highly rated entries in their career remains The Clinic, which stands out as a key performance.

Advertisement

Best Isaiah Mustafa Movies Ranked

Must-watch hits from Isaiah Mustafa's career based on audience ratings.

Full Filmography

Every movie Isaiah Mustafa has appeared in, with audience ratings and verdicts.

YearMovieCharacterSuccessMore
2025 I Know What You Did Last Summer Andrew Average Similar →
2024 Boy Kills World Benny Hit Similar →
2022 Murder at Yellowstone City Cicero Flop Similar →
2022 The Hostage J.R. Flop Similar →
2022 Home Team Porcupine Coach Hit Similar →
2019 The Summers of It - Chapter Two: It Ends Self Hit Similar →
2019 It Chapter Two Mike Hanlon Hit Similar →
2018 The Clinic Fletcher Super Hit Similar →
2017 Five Minutes Roman Flop Similar →
2016 Girl Flu. Gabriel Average Similar →
2016 After the Reality Garreth Average Similar →
2014 Back in the Day T Flop Similar →
2013 Crush Coach Evans Average Similar →
2012 Rags Reginald Worth Hit Similar →
2012 Mansome Self Flop Similar →
2012 The Three Stooges Moe's Hip Executive Average Similar →
2011 Horrible Bosses Officer Wilkens Hit Similar →
2011 Madea's Big Happy Family Calvin Hit Similar →
2011 Thunderballs Ronnie Flop Similar →
2007 Even Money Basketball Player (uncredited) Average Similar →

Isaiah Mustafa - Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best movie of Isaiah Mustafa?

According to audience ratings, the best movie starring Isaiah Mustafa is "The Clinic" with a rating of 10.0/10.

How many movies has Isaiah Mustafa acted in?

Isaiah Mustafa has been featured in at least 20 major films throughout their career.

What are some other popular movies by Isaiah Mustafa?

Other notable films include "Rags", "The Summers of It - Chapter Two: It Ends", and "It Chapter Two".

Advertisement