
J. Farrell MacDonald
ActingAbout J. Farrell MacDonald
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia John Farrell MacDonald (June 6, 1875 – August 2, 1952) was an American character actor and director. He played supporting roles and occasional leads. He appeared in over 325 films over a 41-year career from 1911 to 1951, and directed forty-four silent films from 1912 to 1917. MacDonald was the principal director of L. Frank Baum's Oz Film Manufacturing Company, and he can frequently be seen in the films of Frank Capra, Preston Sturges and, especially, John Ford. Early in his career, MacDonald was a singer in minstrel shows, and he toured the United States extensively for two years with stage productions. He made his first silent film in 1911, a dramatic short entitled The Scarlett Letter made by Carl Laemmle's Independent Moving Pictures Company (IMP), the forerunner of Universal Pictures,. He continued to act in numerous films each year from that time on, and by 1912 he was directing them as well. The first film he directed was The Worth of a Man, another dramatic short, again for IMP, and he was to direct 43 more films until his last in 1917, Over the Fence, which he co-directed with Harold Lloyd. MacDonald had crossed paths with Lloyd several years earlier, when Lloyd was an extra and MacDonald had given him much-needed work – and he did the same with Hal Roach, both of whom appearing in small roles in The Patchwork Girl of Oz, which MacDonald directed in 1914. When Roach set up his own studio, with Lloyd as his principal attraction, he hired MacDonald to direct. By 1918, MacDonald, who was to become one of the most beloved character men in Hollywood, had given up directing and was acting full-time, predominantly in Westerns and Irish comedies. He first worked under director John Ford in 1919's A Fight for Love. In all, Ford would use MacDonald on twenty-five films between 1919 and 1950. With a voice that matched his personality, MacDonald made the transition to sound films easily, with no noticeable drop in his acting output – if anything, it went up. In 1931, for instance, MacDonald appeared in 14 films – among them the first version of The Maltese Falcon, in which he played "Detective Tom Polhaus" – and in 22 of them in 1932. Although he played laborers, policemen, military men and priests, among many other characters, his roles were usually a cut above a "bit part". His characters usually had names, and he was most often credited for his performances. A highlight of this period was his performance as the hobo "Mr. Tramp" in Our Little Girl with Shirley Temple (1935). In the 1940s, MacDonald was part of Preston Sturges' unofficial "stock company" of character actors, appearing in seven films written and directed by Sturges. MacDonald appeared in Sullivan's Travels, The Palm Beach Story, The Miracle of Morgan's Creek, The Great Moment, The Sin of Harold Diddlebock, Unfaithfully Yours and The Beautiful Blonde from Bashful Bend, Sturges' last American film. Earlier, MacDonald had also appeared in The Power and the Glory, which Sturges wrote. His work on Sturges' films was generally uncredited. He was notable in 1946 in John Ford's My Darling Clementine in which he played "Mac," the bartender in the town saloon. MacDonald also had uncredited roles in It's a Wonderful Life and Here Comes The Groom.
Career Statistics & Market Influence
Analyzing the cinematic journey of J. Farrell MacDonald reveals a career defined by exceptional commercial consistency. With a total of 50 major appearances, the actor has established a significant footprint in global cinema.
Genre Dominance: Drama
The majority of J. Farrell MacDonald's filmography leans towards the Drama genre. Audience data suggests that viewers respond most favorably to this persona, though their versatility has allowed for successful crossovers into other categories.
The "Box Office" Signature
With a 88% Success Ratio (movies rated above 6.5), J. Farrell MacDonald remains a reliable draw for studios. Their peak performance was recorded in It's a Wonderful Life, which continues to be the benchmark for their career rating-wise.
Best J. Farrell MacDonald Movies Ranked
Must-watch hits from J. Farrell MacDonald's career based on audience ratings.
Complete Filmography & Success Status
Tracking the career evolution and box office verdicts of J. Farrell MacDonald.
| Year | Movie | Character | Success | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1997 | Barbara Stanwyck: Straight Down The Line | Self (archive footage) | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1951 | Mr. Belvedere Rings the Bell | Mr. Kroeger | Hit | Similar → |
| 1950 | Woman on the Run | Cap, the Retired Ferryboat Captain | Hit | Similar → |
| 1950 | When Willie Comes Marching Home | Gilby - Pharmacist (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1948 | Whispering Smith | Bill Baggs | Hit | Similar → |
| 1948 | Sitting Pretty | Cop (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1948 | If You Knew Susie | Police Sergeant (uncredited) | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1947 | Thunder in the Valley | McPherson - Innkeeper | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1947 | The Bachelor and the Bobby-Soxer | Mac, Bailiff (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1947 | The Sin of Harold Diddlebock | Desk Sergeant (uncredited) | Average | Similar → |
| 1946 | It's a Wonderful Life | Man Whose Grandfather Planted Tree (uncredited) | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1946 | My Darling Clementine | Mac the barman | Hit | Similar → |
| 1945 | Pillow of Death | - | Hit | Similar → |
| 1945 | Fallen Angel | Bank Guard (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1945 | A Tree Grows in Brooklyn | Mr. Carney The Junkman (uncredited) | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1945 | Hangover Square | Street Vendor (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1944 | The Miracle of Morgan’s Creek | Sheriff (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1943 | True to Life | Man (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1942 | The Palm Beach Story | Officer O'Donnell (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1942 | Reap the Wild Wind | Port Captain | Average | Similar → |
| 1942 | Captains of the Clouds | Dr. Neville | Average | Similar → |
| 1941 | The Great Lie | Dr. Ferguson | Hit | Similar → |
| 1941 | Meet John Doe | 'Sourpuss' | Hit | Similar → |
| 1939 | Susannah of the Mounties | Pat O'Hannegan | Average | Similar → |
| 1939 | East Side of Heaven | Doorman (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1938 | Submarine Patrol | CWO 'Sails' Quincannon | Hit | Similar → |
| 1938 | There Goes My Heart | Officer | Hit | Similar → |
| 1938 | The Crowd Roars | Father Patrick Ryan | Hit | Similar → |
| 1937 | Topper | Policeman | Hit | Similar → |
| 1936 | Show Boat | Windy MacLaine | Hit | Similar → |
| 1936 | Exclusive Story | Michael Devlin | Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | Hitch Hike Lady | Judge Hale | Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | Fighting Youth | Coach Parker | Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | The Irish in Us | Capt. Jackson | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | Let 'em Have It | Mr. Keefer | Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | The Whole Town's Talking | Prison Warden (uncredited) | Hit | Similar → |
| 1935 | Romance in Manhattan | Murphy | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1933 | The Working Man | Henry 'Hank' Davis | Hit | Similar → |
| 1932 | No Man of Her Own | "Dickie" Collins | Hit | Similar → |
| 1932 | Scandal for Sale | Treadway | Hit | Similar → |
| 1931 | The Maltese Falcon | Det. Sgt. Tom Polhaus | Average | Similar → |
| 1931 | The Millionaire | Dan Lewis | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1930 | Men Without Women | Costello | Average | Similar → |
| 1928 | 4 Devils | The Clown | Hit | Similar → |
| 1927 | Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans | The Photographer | Super Hit | Similar → |
| 1927 | East Side, West Side | Pug Malone | Hit | Similar → |
| 1926 | 3 Bad Men | Mike Costigan | Hit | Similar → |
| 1925 | The Iron Horse | Corporal Casey | Hit | Similar → |
| 1922 | The Young Rajah | Amhad Beg - Prime Minister | Hit | Similar → |
| 1915 | Rags | Paul Ferguson (as Joseph Farrell MacDonald) | Super Hit | Similar → |
J. Farrell MacDonald - Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best movie of J. Farrell MacDonald?
According to audience ratings, the best movie starring J. Farrell MacDonald is "It's a Wonderful Life" with a rating of 8.3/10.
How many movies has J. Farrell MacDonald acted in?
J. Farrell MacDonald has been featured in at least 50 major films throughout their career.
What are some other popular movies by J. Farrell MacDonald?
Other notable films include "Sunrise: A Song of Two Humans", "Romance in Manhattan", and "The Irish in Us".




