Dynamic Watchlist Hub: Jan 19, 2026

10 Best Movies Like Expecting Amish

If you loved Expecting Amish, we've curated the perfect watchlist for you based on shared genres, themes, and directorial style.

🏆

Expert Review & Ratings

See our full critical analysis and audience score for Expecting Amish.

View Review →
#1
How to Build a Better Boy

How to Build a Better Boy

2014★ 6.4

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of TV Movie. It captures a similar compelling atmosphere.

After inadvertently inputting the qualities of the ideal boyfriend into a high-tech government computer, two social outcasts named Mae and Gabby must contend with Albert, a cyberne...

#2
The Pregnancy Pact

The Pregnancy Pact

2010★ 5.1

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of TV Movie & Drama. It captures a similar emotionally gripping atmosphere.

Inspired by the true story of teenagers at Gloucester High School who agreed to get pregnant at the same time....

#3
Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story

Magic Beyond Words: The J.K. Rowling Story

2011★ 6.9

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of Drama. It captures a similar emotionally gripping atmosphere.

A look at J.K. Rowling from her humble beginnings as an imaginative young girl and awkward teenager, to the loss of her mother and the genesis of the Harry Potter book series....

#4
The Color of Rain

The Color of Rain

2014★ 6.4

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of TV Movie & Drama. It captures a similar emotionally gripping atmosphere.

After cancer claims Matt Kell's life on Christmas Day 2005, his widow, Gina and two young boys are left to cope with the pain of his loss while their close church community gathers...

#5
Abducted: The Carlina White Story

Abducted: The Carlina White Story

2012★ 7.7

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of Drama. It captures a similar emotionally gripping atmosphere.

A baby abducted at birth and raised by the woman who took her, eventually discovers she is a missing child, reconnects with her birth parents, and struggles with choosing between h...

#6
The Biggest Fan

The Biggest Fan

2002★ 6.6

Why watch this? A perfect follow-up to Expecting Amish for fans of Comedy. It captures a similar light-hearted atmosphere.

Dreams come true for young girl (Kayla Amariah) when her idol, heartthrob Chris Trousdale from the boy band Dream Street, must hide out and live in her house....